Skip to content
Trending storyDeveloping

Home Office AI use in asylum and immigration cases faces secrecy and accuracy scrutiny

2 articles2 sourcessince Oct 26Last article

Overview

AISummary of 2 articles

Open Rights Group publishes a report, Automated Discrimination, saying the Home Office has embedded AI across immigration and asylum work in near-total secrecy.

The report cites sham-marriage detection, age checks for asylum seekers, live facial recognition at borders, and case prioritisation through the Ipic tool. It calls for AI regulation and a ban on undemocratic uses. A Home Office spokesperson says AI only assists caseworkers and does not make asylum decisions.

WIRED reports that Open Rights Group found the share of case summaries deemed unfit for use is significantly higher than the 9 percent error rate in the government's pilot evaluation. The generative AI tools, built on OpenAI's GPT-4 and Microsoft Foundry, are not listed in the UK's public repository of government algorithmic tools, and asylum seekers are not told when they are used. The Independent Chief Inspector of Borders and Immigration is considering an investigation, and has asked Open Rights Group for more information as it plans its next inspections.

Written by AI from the articles below · updated Oct 27, 1:38 PM ET

Check the sources:

Developments

2 developments

  1. Oct 27, 11:10 AM ET · 1 article
    UK watchdog considers probe into Home Office use of OpenAI-based asylum tools
    Wired · AI: UK Home Office may face investigation over use of OpenAI-based asylum tools
  2. Oct 26, 8:01 PM ET · 1 article
    Open Rights Group report says Home Office has embedded AI across immigration processes in near-total secrecy
    The Guardian · AI: Open Rights Group report says AI is embedded across the Home Office in near-total secrecy

Article timeline

The articles in this story. Times are ET.

Oct 27
  1. Wired · AINews
    UK Home Office may face investigation over use of OpenAI-based asylum tools

    AIA UK government watchdog is considering an investigation into the Home Office's use of generative AI tools to process asylum applications, WIRED reports. Researchers at Open Rights Group found that the share of case summaries deemed unfit for use is significantly higher than the 9 percent error rate in the government's pilot evaluation. The tools, built on OpenAI's GPT-4 and Microsoft Foundry, are not listed on the UK's public repository of government algorithmic tools, and asylum seekers are not told when they are used.

Oct 26
  1. The Guardian · AINews
    Open Rights Group report says AI is embedded across the Home Office in near-total secrecy

    AIA report by Open Rights Group says the Home Office has embedded AI in tasks including sham-marriage detection, age checks for asylum seekers, live facial recognition at borders, and case prioritisation through the Ipic tool. The report, titled Automated Discrimination, calls for AI regulation, a ban on undemocratic uses, and greater transparency. A Home Office spokesperson says AI only assists caseworkers and does not make asylum decisions.

Heat Trend

Current comparable heat
15
Peak comparable heat
26Oct 27, 12:00 PM ET
Change in past 24 hours
+105%

The trend compares only continuously observed participants, so its scope may be smaller than the current heat total. Hover or tap for hourly heat; use arrow keys with a keyboard.